Unsurprisingly, Homeowners’ Associations (HOAs) are a hot topic. A recent YouGov survey reveals a surprising truth: while one in five Americans live in HOA-governed communities, most prefer the freedom of non-HOA neighborhoods. This article explores how Americans really feel about HOA influence, from property aesthetics to personal freedoms. Join us as we unravel the intricate relationship between Americans and their HOAs, where the conflict between community standards often clashes with the desire for individual autonomy.
General Attitude Towards HOAs
Many Americans, especially those living under HOAs, would prefer not to be governed by them. Despite this, one in five Americans currently lives in an HOA-governed community, and one in three has lived in one at some point.
Demographics of HOA Residents
HOA membership is more common in the South and West of the U.S. and among people with college degrees or higher family incomes.
HOA Fees
Most homeowners in HOA communities pay fees, with about half paying $1,000 or less annually.
Preference for Non-HOA Living
61% of Americans would prefer to live in a neighborhood without an HOA, while only 14% would prefer to live with one.
Perception of HOA’s Impact
More Americans believe HOAs have a negative rather than a positive effect on communities. However, residents of HOA-governed neighborhoods view their impact more positively.
Approval of HOA Governance
Despite some preferring not to live under an HOA, a majority approves of how their HOA is governed, and more than half like living in an HOA neighborhood.
Concerns Over Regulation
Dissatisfaction with HOAs is often due to perceived overregulation, especially regarding rules and regulations set by the HOA.
Support for Specific HOA Regulations
Americans generally support HOA rules on noise levels, trash, and parking, but are more opposed to rules on yard signs, fences, landscaping, pet ownership, exterior paint colors, home renovations, and holiday decorations.
Characteristics of HOA Neighborhoods
HOA neighborhoods tend to have houses built close together, similar in appearance, and occupied by people from the same social class.
